.
Feedback

Morton Chalfy's Blog: A Reflection on Giving

There but for the grace of God go I...

“Everybody is somebody.” My grandfather would occasionally use that phrase to explain to my long-suffering grandmother why he had brought yet another homeless person to their tiny apartment to share a meal. This was back in the depths of the Depression when my grandmother was feeding five children by making every scrap of food turn into nutrition. No waste, clean your plate and eat a piece of bread with that. Forty years later she was still using every part of every piece of edible food that came into her house.

My grandfather was following the dictates of the Talmud as he understood them and charity to others was a prime tenet. While he never handed out cash he was quick to share what he did have and would get righteously upset if questioned too closely by my grandmother. Who had the better argument? That was the meat of the conundrum of ethics that my family chewed over. Grampa who couldn’t stand others’ suffering or Grandma who already was performing miracles with meager rations?

I dearly loved my grandmother, but I understood Grampa’s feelings. Whether he had been instructed by his religion or not he couldn’t abide people going hungry when he had food to share. The basis of that feeling, I believe, was his empathy.  Everyone he looked at stirred the feeling “there but for the grace of God go I" in him. He could clearly see the essential family relationship of all of us and felt the pangs of other’s hunger as though it was his own.

The most difficult lesson to learn, I think, is that everybody IS somebody.  Survival of the fittest refers to species, not individuals. We are all expressions of the human DNA and as such we are all siblings. It is so easy to dismiss the entire rest of the population of the world, except for the few we consider family, as not human, not important, too different to be like me.  These, or any other of the rationales we use to  diminish the worth of other lives. In our money-worshipping society the denigration of the poor is endemic in the culture.

 But “they” are us. It was easier to recognize this when we all lived tribal lives, when we were all related.  Now, in our atomized existence, it is easier to dismiss the lives of others as their problem, not ours.  That is a failure of imagination and a lack of empathy. None of us is safe from disaster, misfortune, bankruptcy, devastation and death. We share the human condition and helping one another is, in my grandfather’s mind, a “mitzvah” or good deed. 

In order to understand another person it’s important to be able to put yourself in his or her place in your imagination, to feel what they feel, to see through their point of view. It’s actually easy to do once you understand that it could be you in the same situation if your life circumstances had been different.

I do understand that with seven billion of us walking around it is passing difficult to see us all as individuals. Still, that is the actual fact of life. Everybody is somebody.

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Alameda Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Loading comments ...
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Jeff Mark May 19, 2013 at 12:34 am
Or we could wait until just watching them isn't enough of a thrill...
Jeff Mark May 19, 2013 at 12:17 am
Fine, call the non-emergency number, but call. I strongly disagree with the above. I think callingRead More the couples "exhibitionists" is totally unfair. What they're doing is reasonably normal; what he's doing is, well... At the risk of making a possibly extreme comparison, this is how "Son of Sam" started; first he stalked couples making out in the back seats of their cars, then he started shooting them. Someone needs to talk to this guy. Someone with a badge.
Craig Long May 18, 2013 at 11:56 pm
Also, I don't think it is a matter for the authorities anyway. I'm not so sure who would be at faultRead More here, the exhibitionist, or the peeper.
Jeff Mark May 18, 2013 at 10:28 pm
I think this headline is unfairly worded. I think Webster St. is, for example, substantiallyRead More "cleaner" (whatever that means) than it was, say, fifteen or twenty years ago. We need to give credit for that. What Gavin would seem to be looking for might, I aver, be more appropriately called "gentrification", a trend that has its unfortunate side, but does bring in the Pasta Pomodoros and the Jamba Juices. Actually, I would expect to see stores like that more at soon-to-be-Alameda Landing, but perhaps that's another discussion.
http://youtu.be/RhRFhyneFcw
Vicster May 18, 2013 at 08:36 am
I'm so glad he hadn't wandered away! I bike home from the ferry along Santa Clara and I kept an eyeRead More out for him. Sounds like he had himself a nice time, the cheeky monkey!
Analisa Harangozo (Editor) May 17, 2013 at 05:51 pm
Yay! I'm glad! Thanks for the update Suzanne.
Suzanne Chenier May 17, 2013 at 05:48 pm
Found!!! He followed me into my downstairs neighbor's house. I went to borrow some eggs. My neighborRead More was at work. I didn't know he followed me in, didn't see or hear him, got the eggs and left. I called that brat for over three hours. He raided my neighbor's garbage can and a bachelor nap on his sofa! Yay. I'm glad he's home and safe. Thank you everyone.
Lion's Mane May 18, 2013 at 03:31 pm
Good point, Gevin! Forgot about the dog park!! Recently a woman with a big, off-leash Rott stoodRead More by and watched him take a huge dump at the water's edge, then she continued on her way without cleaning it up. The park police got here in time and paid her a visit, and she was none to happy about that...made my day. Unfortunately, a family with 2 little kiddos set up their blanket right in front of the Rottie's toilet spot shortly after she walked away, and I'm sure the kids were all over it. The no-dogs allowed ruling was probably inspired, at least in part, by irresponsible pet owners like her.
Gevin Says May 18, 2013 at 12:54 pm
Especially since there is a special DOG PARK just for your little Poopsie to play too!
Gevin Says May 18, 2013 at 01:08 pm
I would say it's the school's responsibility, but it all starts at home. How you are raised, howRead More you act, and how children around you watch how you act. If you do something wrong, and a child see's it, they may think it's okay to do it since they saw a grown up do it.
jason schabert May 17, 2013 at 12:01 am
sorry but the photo wasn't uploaded
Kimberlee MacVicar May 17, 2013 at 02:36 pm
Thanks for the info about your experience. I'm starting to hear the same story from about 7 peopleRead More now and I'm sure there are more. Store has been closed all week. Still no sign on the door. At a loss as to what to do to find out what's going on or what to do next.
bette page May 17, 2013 at 07:01 am
Good luck with that. I stopped patronizing them a year ago after some shifty practices with my highRead More end items: wouldn't give me a receipt and then my items sat untagged for three weeks. Completely missed the xmas shopping season.
photo originally posted by Dennis Domingo
Analisa Harangozo (Editor) May 15, 2013 at 07:15 pm
Carol, posted this on Facebook and got some responses so far:Read More https://www.facebook.com/AlamedaPatch/posts/666500700043838?comment_id=32723444&offset=0&total_comments=2
An accident occurred Monday, May 13 on Westline/8th Street turning into Crown Beach. Credit: Jessica McMahon
Carol Parker May 15, 2013 at 11:02 am
It is really dangerous coming out of the dog park/tennis court parking lot. We never try to turnRead More left coming out of it, always right - and even then you have to be super careful because cars just come speeding down the street.